Homemade Toothpaste vs Store Bought Toothpaste: Which is Cheaper?

Mick Strickland

When it comes to oral hygiene, toothpaste is an essential item that is used daily by millions of people around the world. Toothpaste helps to clean teeth, freshen breath, and prevent cavities. With so many different types of toothpaste available on the market, it can be difficult to know which one to choose. One question that often arises is whether homemade toothpaste is cheaper than store-bought toothpaste.

Homemade toothpaste has become increasingly popular in recent years, as people look for more natural and sustainable alternatives to traditional products. Making your own toothpaste can be a cost-effective option, as many of the ingredients can be found in your pantry or at your local health food store. However, it’s important to consider whether homemade toothpaste is as effective as store-bought toothpaste, and whether it is worth the effort and time required to make it.

The Cost of Homemade Toothpaste

Ingredients

Making homemade toothpaste can be a cost-effective alternative to buying store-bought toothpaste. The ingredients used in homemade toothpaste are usually all-natural and can be found at your local grocery store or health food store. The most common ingredients used in homemade toothpaste are baking soda, coconut oil, and essential oils like peppermint or tea tree oil.

Other ingredients that can be added include sea salt, calcium powder, and xylitol. The cost of these ingredients can vary depending on where you purchase them and the quantity you buy. For example, a 16 oz. box of baking soda can cost around $1, while a jar of coconut oil can cost around $10 for 16 oz. A small bottle of essential oil can cost around $5.

Equipment

In addition to the ingredients, you will also need some basic equipment to make homemade toothpaste. This includes a mixing bowl, measuring spoons, and a container to store the toothpaste in. These items can be found in most households and are relatively inexpensive. If you don’t have them on hand, you can purchase them at a dollar store or online for a few dollars.

Overall, the cost of making homemade toothpaste can be significantly less than buying store-bought toothpaste. While the initial investment in ingredients and equipment may seem high, they can be used to make multiple batches of toothpaste, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.

The Cost of Store Bought Toothpaste

When it comes to toothpaste, there are countless options available at your local grocery or drugstore. From name brand toothpaste to generic store brand options, the cost of toothpaste can vary greatly. However, one thing is for sure, store bought toothpaste can be expensive.

According to a report by Statista, the average price of toothpaste in the United States was $3.63 in 2020. However, this price can vary greatly depending on the brand, size, and type of toothpaste. For example, a tube of sensitive teeth toothpaste can cost upwards of $5, while a tube of whitening toothpaste can cost over $7.

It’s important to note that toothpaste is not a one-time purchase. Most people use toothpaste twice a day, every day, which means they need to purchase toothpaste regularly. This can add up quickly, especially for families with multiple people who all need toothpaste.

In addition to the cost of toothpaste, there are also environmental concerns to consider. Most toothpaste tubes are made of non-recyclable plastic, which means they end up in landfills. This can have a negative impact on the environment.

Overall, while store bought toothpaste is convenient and readily available, it can be expensive and have negative environmental impacts. This is why some people choose to make their own toothpaste at home using natural ingredients.

Comparing the Costs

Homemade toothpaste can be a cost-effective alternative to store-bought toothpaste, but it depends on the ingredients used and how often it is made. The cost of homemade toothpaste varies depending on the recipe and the availability of the ingredients.

On average, a tube of toothpaste costs between $3 to $6, depending on the brand and size. Homemade toothpaste can cost less than store-bought toothpaste, especially if the ingredients are bought in bulk or are readily available at home. For example, a simple recipe using baking soda and water can cost as little as a few cents per batch.

However, some homemade toothpaste recipes may require expensive or hard-to-find ingredients, which can drive up the cost. For instance, a recipe that calls for essential oils or xylitol can be more expensive than store-bought toothpaste.

It’s also important to consider the time and effort required to make homemade toothpaste. While it may be cheaper, it can be time-consuming to make and may not be as convenient as store-bought toothpaste.

Overall, the cost of homemade toothpaste can vary depending on the recipe and ingredients used. It can be a cost-effective alternative to store-bought toothpaste, but it’s important to consider the cost of ingredients, time, and effort required to make it.

Other Factors to Consider

Effectiveness

One concern with homemade toothpaste is its effectiveness. While some studies have shown that DIY toothpaste can be just as effective at removing plaque as store-bought toothpaste, it is important to note that not all homemade toothpaste recipes are created equal. Some ingredients may not have the same abrasiveness or fluoride content as commercial toothpaste, which can affect their ability to clean teeth and prevent cavities.

It is important to do thorough research and consult with a dentist before using homemade toothpaste as a replacement for commercial toothpaste.

Safety

Another factor to consider is the safety of homemade toothpaste. While many ingredients used in DIY toothpaste are natural and safe, some can be harmful to teeth and gums. For example, using baking soda as a primary ingredient may be too abrasive and damage tooth enamel over time. Similarly, using acidic ingredients like lemon juice can erode tooth enamel and cause sensitivity.

It is important to be cautious when using homemade toothpaste and to avoid ingredients that can be harmful to teeth and gums. Always consult with a dentist before using homemade toothpaste as a replacement for commercial toothpaste.

Convenience

Using homemade toothpaste can also present some challenges in terms of convenience. Unlike commercial toothpaste, which can be easily purchased at any grocery or drug store, homemade toothpaste requires more effort and preparation to make.

Additionally, homemade toothpaste may not have the same shelf life as commercial toothpaste and may need to be made more frequently. This can be inconvenient for those who prefer a more low-maintenance oral hygiene routine.

However, for those who enjoy making their own products and have the time and resources to do so, homemade toothpaste can be a fun and rewarding alternative to commercial toothpaste.